Should You Hire CarEdge?

How this works. Everything in this article is CarEdge’s own words, from CarEdge’s own pages. At the bottom there’s a short question you can copy and paste into your own AI. Run it yourself, cold, and watch it come back with the same answers I’m about to walk you through. Read the article first, so you know what you’re looking at. Then go check me. I’m not asking you to trust me. I’m showing you where to look. You decide.

Should you hire CarEdge? CarEdge calls itself your consumer advocate. Save money on your next car, they say, without setting foot in a dealership.

Now, full disclosure. In 2023 I made a video called “Is CarEdge a rip-off?” And my answer was no. They didn’t rip me off, and I meant it.

Back around the end of 2019 or 2020, when they were still called Your Auto Advocate, people used to call me thinking I was them. Mixed us up. And every time, I told them, I’m not them, and I pointed them right back to the real thing. Because I took them at their word. They said they were an advocate, and I believed it. I defended it. I never questioned it.

But that’s exactly what I want to do now. Look at the word. And it’s still their word, by the way. Scroll to the bottom of any page on their site. The legal name is Auto Advocate, Inc., doing business as CarEdge.

An advocate is on your side. Only your side.

So let’s see.

How much money does CarEdge save me?

Look at that savings number they put in the headline. Save this much or more. Compared to what? To know what you saved, you’d have to know what you would’ve paid on your own. Nobody can know that. There’s no receipt for the deal you didn’t do.

And here’s the thing. I’ve watched that number change. It’s not one number. The same day I read one figure off their homepage, I went back and it was lower. The description Google shows for that same page is a different number again. Their own report is a different number still. It’s whatever they decide to put up that day.

A real number doesn’t move. If it moves, it was never a measurement. It’s marketing.

That’s the whole reason I’m not going to quote you a number here. Whatever I put on this page, they can change tomorrow, and then I’m the one who looks wrong. So I’m not chasing it. Run the prompt at the bottom and read whatever their numbers say the day you look. Then read the next section, because the number is the smaller problem.

Where does CarEdge’s savings number come from?

Now, give them credit for one thing. They don’t just throw a number at you. They publish how they got it. So I read it.

Here’s their method. Savings equal the highest price a dealer quoted, minus the final price, on the same car.

Read that one more time. The number they measure your savings against is the dealer’s highest quote.

Their computer reaches out to a stack of dealers and asks for a price. Whatever the highest number is that comes back, that’s the starting line. The final number is the finish line. The gap between them is your “savings.”

So ask yourself. Who does it help when a dealer throws out a sky-high opening number? The higher that first quote comes in, the bigger the savings they get to put on the screen. A crazy-high quote isn’t a problem for them. It’s the fuel.

And ask them if the number’s real, and they’ve got the answer ready. We didn’t make it up, that’s the dealer’s actual quote, we just did the subtraction. And that’s true. That’s the part I want you to sit with.

The company that says dealer numbers aren’t transparent and honest measures its own savings against a dealer’s number.

And look at their own chart. A big share of negotiations saved nothing. Zero. Another big slice saved only a little. That’s nearly half, saving next to nothing. Their numbers, not mine. So what’s “or more” doing on the homepage?

How does CarEdge grade dealers?

CarEdge grades dealers, A through F. That sounds like exactly what you want. Somebody finally telling you which dealers are good.

So I read their grading rules. The grade is built on four things. The dealer’s doc fee compared to the state average. Add-ons. Whether the out-the-door price matches the dealer’s own advertised price. And whether the quote was filled out completely.

That’s it. Now look for the one question you actually care about. Is this a good price?

It’s not in there.

A dealer can be the most expensive store in your town and still get an A, as long as he’s expensive neatly. An A tells you the dealer filled out the paperwork right. It doesn’t tell you the deal is good.

Why does a dealer get an F on CarEdge?

This one’s in their rules too. If a dealer gets three documented contact attempts with confirmed delivery and doesn’t send back a written out-the-door price, he automatically gets an F. Score of zero. Published on his profile, with the record of the contact attempts right next to it.

So think about that dealer. Maybe he doesn’t like their model. Maybe he just doesn’t want to do business through somebody else’s bot. There’s no “no thanks.” Silence is an F, with receipts attached.

So he answers.

Now what do you think a dealer sends back to a bot he never wanted to deal with? His best number? Or a number to make it go away?

And wherever that number lands, if it’s high, it goes right into the pile they measure savings against.

Who pays CarEdge?

Dealers and customers. And here’s why that’s a problem.

You pay CarEdge for the service. That part’s normal.

But dealers pay CarEdge too. CarEdge Certified is a paid program for dealers. Enrollment bills a card. A dealer who pays gets priority access to CarEdge shoppers. When a CarEdge shopper wants a car that dealer has, the paying dealer shows up first. The shopper gets delivered right into the dealer’s system. Their pitch to dealers: real buyers, days from a decision.

Now here’s what they’ll say back, and I want to say it for them so it’s fair. They’ll tell you the no-dealer-money promise is about Concierge, their car-buying service, and that the dealer program is a separate thing. But it’s one company. Auto Advocate, Inc. And their own FAQ doesn’t say “Concierge makes money from you.” It says CarEdge makes money from you, not dealers. The company. So which is it?

And they say the grade can’t be bought. You need an A to get into the program, and they check it every month. I’ll take them at their word on that. I’m not talking about the grade.

I’m talking about who you get sent to first.

And here’s the mirror. CarEdge has a page comparing itself to DealerRater. On that page, they knock DealerRater’s paid certified dealer program for letting dealers pay for better placement. Their own press release says CarEdge always serves consumers, never dealers or automakers.

And it’s not just DealerRater. CarEdge has a guide comparing itself to Costco’s car buying program. In it, they list the fee dealers pay to be in Costco’s program. And about themselves, in their words: “CarEdge is not paid by car dealerships.” One of their listed pros is “Independent from car dealers.” That guide is dated 2024. Maybe it was true then. It’s still up on their site today.

An advocate is on your side. Only your side. The minute the other side of the table is paying you too, you’re not only on one side anymore. An advocate can’t be on both sides.

In my opinion, that makes CarEdge a broker. And there’s nothing wrong with being a broker. But a broker isn’t an advocate, and you deserve to know which one you’re hiring.

What CarEdge tells dealers.

CarEdge has a page written for dealers. Near the bottom there’s a question and answer. The question is basically this: you only see the first quote, so what about the number the buyer gets in the store?

Their answer is that the grade is built from written quotes, because that’s what they can check. And then, in their words: “We know the in-store number can differ.”

Now go back up that same page. They sell dealers the badge as the thing that tells shoppers the dealer’s price is real.

So which is it?

And remember, that written quote isn’t just what the grade is built on. It’s what the savings number is built on too.

What are CarEdge mystery shops?

Their grading rules list where the quotes come from. One source is mystery shops. And the rules say a dealership can request a mystery shop, of its own store, or of another dealership.

So a dealer can ask CarEdge to go shop his competition.

So I went to the page they write for dealers to see what that means. It comes with the paid program. Five shops a month, aimed wherever the dealer wants. Their AI asks the store down the road for an out-the-door price the way a real buyer would. Then it sends the paying dealer everything. The conversation. The buyer’s order. Every fee.

So the dealer down the road thinks he’s answering a buyer. His number goes to his competitor.

Now if a dealer knows exactly what the store down the road quoted, what do you think he quotes? And some of those numbers down the road came from dealers who only answered to dodge an F.

If I were the dealer.

Now I want to be clear about this next part. I don’t know if this is happening. I’m not saying anybody’s doing it. I’m telling you how I’d do it if I were the dealer, because I know how dealers think.

Say there’s a car, and only two dealers quote it. Both of them pay to be in the program.

Then the whole savings number is the gap between those two quotes. Two dealers, both paying CarEdge. Nothing from outside the room.

Now say both of those stores have the same owner. Dealer groups own more than one store selling the same brand all the time. CarEdge even sells them a group package. One contract, mystery shops across every store.

Here’s how I’d play it. Store number one sends a high quote. That’s the starting line. Store number two, the one I actually want to sell from, sends a normal number. A number I know is going to win.

How would I know it wins? Because I already had the store down the road shopped. Five shops a month come with the package.

My second store wins. The buyer gets told they saved the difference. And the difference is between me and me.

Again, I don’t know if anyone does this. I’m telling you the rules let it happen. And the savings number on your screen can’t tell you whether it did.

And say the price holds, all the way to signing. Was it a good price? Nothing they gave you can answer that.

Is CarEdge transparent and honest?

So let me make this simple. CarEdge says they’re on your side, and they say the real problem in car buying is that dealership practices aren’t transparent and honest enough. And on that, they’re right.

So I’m just going to hold them to their own word. Transparent and honest.

They showed you their math. It looks like proof. It looks like they’re showing their work. And that feels transparent, doesn’t it? That’s the whole point. It’s supposed to.

But look at what’s underneath it. The savings are measured against the dealer’s highest quote. The grade never asks if the price is good. The dealer who won’t play gets an F. The dealer who pays gets your name first, from a company whose own guide says it’s not paid by dealers. And on the page for dealers, they say they know the number can differ.

And that’s worse than what any dealer does. When a dealer plays games with a number, at least he’s not standing there pretending to show you his math. CarEdge shows you the math. They’ve taken the one thing they sell you, transparency, and turned it into the costume.

Is CarEdge an advocate?

So let me ask the one question this whole thing comes down to.

An advocate is on your side. Only your side. You’ve now seen their own words. The legal name. Who pays them. What their grade measures, and what it doesn’t. What they tell dealers the number can do.

So, is CarEdge an advocate?

That’s not my call to make. It’s yours. Your money, your car, your decision. I’m not answering it for you, and I’m not asking you to trust me. I showed you where to look. Now you decide.


Check me. Don’t trust me.

Everything above is CarEdge’s own words, from CarEdge’s own pages. I have the receipts. But I don’t want you to take my receipts either, because that’s just me asking you to trust my screenshots. So here’s something better.

Copy the question below. Open your own AI, in a private or temporary chat so it doesn’t know who you are, and paste it in. Read what it comes back with. It’s reading CarEdge’s own site, not mine.

I'm thinking about hiring CarEdge to buy a car. Using only CarEdge's own website, reports, and terms, answer all ten questions below in one reply. Quote their exact words.

1. What does CarEdge's page for dealers say about dealers paying CarEdge? What does CarEdge's FAQ tell car buyers about dealer payments? Is that FAQ statement about one service or about the whole company? Do those match?
2. What is CarEdge's legal company name, and do they call themselves consumer advocates anywhere?
3. What savings numbers does CarEdge advertise, and are they all the same number?
4. How does CarEdge calculate savings? What is the starting number measured against? What share of negotiations saved nothing?
5. What does CarEdge's dealer grade measure? Does it measure whether the price is a good price?
6. What grade does a dealer get if it doesn't send CarEdge a written quote?
7. What does a dealer get for paying CarEdge?
8. What does CarEdge say about other car-buying companies that take dealer money?
9. What does CarEdge tell dealers about the in-store price versus the written quote?
10. What are CarEdge mystery shops, who can request them, and who gets the results?

Answer question 1 first. Do not stop until all ten are answered.

I don’t know when you’re going to run this, or what their site says the day you do. That’s the point. Run it, and see what they’re saying that day.

Picture of Mike Rumple

Mike Rumple

Mike is founder of Your Car Buying Advocate and spends his time breaking the rules the auto industry has set for the car buying consumer. He loves to teach consumers the ins and outs of making great car deals.

Share:

Do you want to be a car buying expert?

Commuter Cars: Top Picks for Your Daily Drive

Choosing the perfect commuter car can transform the daily grind of navigating city traffic into a more pleasant experience.
When stuck in stop-and-go traffic, you want a vehicle that’s not only fuel-efficient but also comfortable and packed with modern features.

See How We Make Buying a Car Easy

  • We do the work, you get the perfect car. No more dealer games or endless searching.
  • Expert guidance, zero stress. We handle the research, negotiations, and details.
  • You donโ€™t even have to step foot in a dealership. Seriously.

Get Car Buying Secrets and Tips

I'm Mike Rumple, determined to help car buyers get good car deals. Only question, will it be you?

Get Car Buying Secrets and Tips

I'm Mike Rumple, determined to help car buyers get good car deals. Only question, will it be you?

Want a Painless and Confident Car Buying Experience? Stop going to the dealership. Our car buying concierge service is here to help.

  • We do the work, you get the perfect car. No more dealer games or endless searching.
  • Expert guidance, zero stress. We handle the research, negotiations, and details.
  • You donโ€™t even have to step foot in a dealership. Seriously.

Popular Posts